In partnership with
CAPTIVATED: unlocking what makes us tick, click, and buy, with psychology-backed tips and behavioral science shortcuts.
Today’s Edition of Captivated: The Sunk Cost Fallacy: How Past Commitment Shapes Current Decisions
🧠 SMART TOOLS YOU CAN USE: FROM OUR SPONSORS
This newsletter you couldn’t wait to open? It runs on beehiiv — the absolute best platform for email newsletters.
Our editor makes your content look like Picasso in the inbox. Your website? Beautiful and ready to capture subscribers on day one.
And when it’s time to monetize, you don’t need to duct-tape a dozen tools together. Paid subscriptions, referrals, and a (super easy-to-use) global ad network — it’s all built in.
beehiiv isn’t just the best choice. It’s the only choice that makes sense.
“We’ve already put so much time into it, makes sense to keep going…”
That one sentence explains a lot of human behavior.
We stay in relationships because we’ve already invested so much time.
We stay through a mediocre movie because we already paid for the ticket.
We keep working toward a goal because we’ve already put months into it.
This pattern shows up everywhere because the brain treats past investment like evidence.
Time, money, energy, and attention all register as signals that something matters, and once those signals exist, they become part of how future choices are evaluated.
Past commitment shapes how decisions feel, how progress is interpreted, and how continuation starts to make sense over time.
This is the Sunk Cost Fallacy.
It influences how people stick with products, stay in relationships, keep habits, and decide whether something feels worth continuing. It also shapes how loyalty forms, especially when progress feels personal and effort feels meaningful.
(continues below).
🎧 Rather Listen than Read?
Scroll all the way to the top and click: Listen Online / Hit the Play icon
🧭 INSIDE THIS EDITION
📈 FUN FACT: DID YOU KNOW?
In a classic study by Arkes & Blumer, people who paid more for theater subscriptions attended more performances afterward, even when enjoyment was low.
🧠
.. How Did We Get Here? ..
Human decision-making is cumulative.
Each choice leaves behind information, and the brain naturally stores past effort, time, and resources as meaningful data. Once an investment exists, it becomes part of the context the brain uses to evaluate what comes next.
Past commitment functions like a reference point.
Time already spent, progress already made, and effort already exerted begin to carry weight in future decisions, even when those investments cannot be recovered. The brain treats them as signals that the choice mattered, that it had purpose, and that continuing maintains coherence with that earlier effort.
This is why commitment strengthens over time.
As investment accumulates, it shapes expectations, identity, and momentum. What started as a single choice gradually turns into a pattern of follow-through, where continuing feels aligned with the story the brain is already telling about progress and direction.
In consumer behavior, this shows up wherever people build history.
Setup steps, learning curves, saved work, personalization, and repeated use all deepen commitment by adding context the brain considers relevant. The more history that exists, the more that history can become part of how future decisions are evaluated.
🧠
.. Brain Science-Backed: The Psychology Behind It ..
🧠 LOSS AVERSION:
Our brains assign strong emotional weight to losing resources.
Money, time, and effort carry an internal ‘value tag’ that lingers in memory. When an investment exists, the brain treats follow-through as a way to protect the value of that investment.
That stored value becomes part of the mental accounting the brain uses when deciding whether to continue.
🧠 COGNITIVE DISSONANCE REGULATION:
Our brains seek internal consistency between actions and identity.
When someone invests in a decision, their self-image begins to align with it: “I’m the kind of person who follows through,” “I make smart choices,” “I commit.”
Continuing supports that sense of coherence. It feels calming, reduces mental friction and supports confidence in one’s own judgment.
Past commitment provides continuity, and continuity supports confidence in ongoing decisions.
🧠 EFFORT JUSTIFICATION:
Effort functions like a value amplifier.
When something requires setup, learning, practice, or time, the brain often assigns it higher importance. The effort becomes part of the information the brain references when evaluating the value of continuing.
This shows up in onboarding flows, streaks, progress tracking, personalization, and earned status systems. People value what they build with their own hands and attention.
🧠 EMOTIONAL OWNERSHIP:
Investment creates a sense of psychological ownership.
As people spend time, effort, or attention on something, it begins to feel personally connected to them.
Progress, saved work, personalization, and history all strengthen this attachment. Over time, the experience becomes associated with identity and momentum, making continued engagement feel natural and self-consistent.
🧠 SMART TOOLS YOU CAN USE: FROM OUR SPONSORS
Shoppers are adding to cart for the holidays
Peak streaming time continues after Black Friday on Roku, with the weekend after Thanksgiving and the weeks leading up to Christmas seeing record hours of viewing. Roku Ads Manager makes it simple to launch last-minute campaigns targeting viewers who are ready to shop during the holidays. Use first-party audience insights, segment by demographics, and advertise next to the premium ad-supported content your customers are streaming this holiday season.
Read the guide to get your CTV campaign live in time for the holiday rush.
🥷
.. Use this Psychology Strategy ..
Here’s how to design with the understanding that past commitment shapes what comes next:
1: CREATE EARLY INVESTMENT WITH IMMEDIATE PAYOFF
Give people a quick moment where effort turns into something tangible:
Add one setup step that produces an instant visible win (a personalized dashboard, a saved plan, a first recommendation, etc.).
Add a first milestone that can be reached in under five minutes.
Add a before vs after view that updates as soon as they complete one action.
2: TURN PROGRESS INTO A LIVING ASSET
People stay when progress feels useful:
Add a progress snapshot that updates weekly: “Here’s what you’ve done so far.”
Add a “continue where you left off” entry point that lands them in momentum.
Add a saved-history feature that becomes more valuable over time (templates, preferences, past results, or saved items).
Progress becomes a resource they can feel. These ‘living assets’ give the brain concrete history to reference when deciding what comes next.
3: INVITE RECOMMITMENT IN A WAY THAT FEELS EMPOWERING
Recommitment works best when it feels like an intentional choice:
Add a simple monthly check-in: “Keep going with this plan?” with options.
Add a “choose your focus” selector that resets their path around what they want now.
Add a “set your next small goal” prompt that turns staying into a clear decision.
Recommitment invites the brain to consciously include past progress while choosing the next step.
🧠 SMART TOOLS YOU CAN USE: FROM OUR SPONSORS
Make Every Platform Work for Your Ads
Marketers waste millions on bad creatives.
You don’t have to.
Neurons AI predicts effectiveness in seconds.
Not days. Not weeks.
Test for recall, attention, impact, and more; before a dollar gets spent.
Brands like Google, Facebook, and Coca-Cola already trust it. Neurons clients saw results like +73% CTR, 2x CVR, and +20% brand awareness.
✌
.. tl;dr & captivated wrap-up ..
The Sunk Cost Fallacy reveals something deeply human about how we move through the world: effort carries meaning, and that meaning becomes part of how future choices are evaluated.
When we invest time, energy, or attention, the brain naturally treats that investment as part of a larger story about progress, identity, and follow-through. Continuing feels aligned because it honors what has already been given.
When people can see what they’ve built, understand how it fits into their goals, and feel a sense of completion along the way, commitment becomes a steady, self-reinforcing process.
The real opportunity is designing systems that respect effort as something valuable, visible, and purposeful.
When progress is clear and ownership feels earned, people stay engaged because it makes sense to them. That kind of commitment lasts, grows, and leaves people feeling captivated and confident in the choices they’ve made.
👋 Until next time,
Profit Nic
What did you think of this edition?
.